On this page
At a glance
- Construction
- Long 1 low strike, short 2 middle strike, long 1 high strike
- Max payoff
- Distance between adjacent strikes, at the middle strike
- Risk (long)
- Limited to the debit paid
Worked example
Underlying at 100, 30 days, 20% implied volatility, zero rates. Buy the 95 call for 5.57, sell two 100 calls for 2.29 each, buy the 105 call for 0.64: the butterfly costs 5.57 − 4.57 + 0.64 = 1.64. At expiry it is worth 5 if the underlying is exactly at 100, declines linearly to 0 at 95 and 105, and is worthless outside. Breakevens are 96.64 and 103.36; the maximum gain is 5 − 1.64 = 3.36.
| Underlying at expiry | Value | P&L |
|---|---|---|
| 95 or below | 0 | −1.64 |
| 96.64 | 1.64 | 0 |
| 100 | 5.00 | +3.36 |
| 103.36 | 1.64 | 0 |
| 105 or above | 0 | −1.64 |
What the price of a butterfly says
Because a narrow butterfly pays off only if the underlying finishes near the middle strike, its price divided by its maximum payoff approximates the risk-neutral probability of that region, discounted. In the limit of very close strikes, the butterfly price per unit of width squared converges to the risk-neutral density of the terminal price. This is why no-arbitrage requires butterfly prices to be non-negative, a constraint that fitted volatility smiles must respect.
Greeks and uses
- Near the middle strike and close to expiry, a long butterfly is short gamma and long theta: it wants the underlying to stay still.
- Far from the middle strike, it becomes long gamma: it needs price to move back toward the centre.
- Traders use butterflies to target a price at expiry cheaply, for example near a large strike, and short-dated index butterflies are popular because their cost is low.
- The 1-2-1 ratio means the legs do not share a size, which matters for detecting them on a flow tape.
In Senzoukria
Senzoukria does not price butterflies. On its Option Flow tape, a butterfly's legs print in a 1-2-1 ratio, so the MULTI tag, which groups different contracts of the same size printed within 25 milliseconds, groups the two wings but not the doubled middle leg; the middle leg can then look like a large directional sale. The documentation notes that spread legs priced separately can defeat the detection rules.
Related
In the same section
- Buy-side and sell-side liquidity
- Bridge
- Buying and selling pressure
- Breakeven win rate
- CAGR
- Breakeven stop
- Calendar spread
- Bracket order
This page in other languages
Frequently asked questions
- Why are butterflies so cheap?
- Because they pay only in a narrow range around the middle strike, which the market assigns a limited probability. The cost reflects that probability; a cheap butterfly is not a bargain by default.
- Is a butterfly the same as the 25-delta butterfly in volatility markets?
- No. The 25-delta butterfly is a volatility quote measuring the curvature of the smile. The butterfly spread is a traded structure of three strikes. The names are related because both describe the relationship between the wings and the centre.